Hi everyone and welcome to the second of three posts for the next two days! Counting down to Christmas, Pete and I are posting our reviews for the three short stories that make up Let It Snow by John Green, Lauren Myracle and Maureen Johnson.
Today’s review is for the second story of Let It Snow, A Cheertastic Christmas Miracle by John Green. Would you rather be snowed in with your best friends watching movies? Or in a Waffle House with 14 cheerleaders practicing lifts? Tobin and JP prefer the cheerleaders right away, but the Duke (Angie, in other words) is all for watching James Bond. After an adventure in the snow, Tobin and JP get their wishes…but Tobin also gets the surprise of his life. A sweet story of love and hash browns, what will Tobin receive this Christmas?
Beth’s Review
I have to admit something before we start. I kind of hold grudges against John Green. It all started with The Fault in Our Stars, which I can’t help thinking was horribly overrated. My thoughts kind of picked up with Paper Towns, where I happened to be one of the only people who loved it. Looking For Alaska was similar – I couldn’t help being captivated. But it all went to rock-bottom when I got around to An Abundance of Katherine’s.
Since then, I have to admit I haven’t looked at this author in a great light. And unfortunately after this story, I’m now just thinking even worse. To put it pessimistically, this book could have been written by anyone else who has read (and studied the trends in) John Green books. It had a guy who would do absolutely anything for the girl he’s suddenly in love with (for no apparent reason). It had a girl who didn’t really do anything but suddenly has a guy after her (sorry, Angie). It even had the random Asian friend who always seems to be thrown in simply to be Politically Correct. The love is instant, with hardly any hesitation or excitement. Overall, to put it simply, it’s started pi**ing me off big time. With all that aside let’s get it over with, and discuss the things I really didn’t like about this story.
♥ Normal, relatable characters being glorified by exotic names and an adventure
♥ A cliche, easy-to-predict plot♥ A very simple love story with no guessing or surprise
So as you can see, I was pretty disappointed with this story overall. Did I like anything? It may not sound like it, but I did! I promise! So let’s go back to listing and discuss what I enjoyed.
♥ The setting! As with the first story, the setting suited the plot and made it kind of exciting. But at the same time, is this Christmas? Kinda, I guess. But it’s more winter than Christmas…I could have easily forgotten it was Christmas Eve as it was hardly mentioned at all!
♥ A lot of little quirks and creative tweaks I would never be able to think up. There was a lot of cool (no pun intended) moments in the snow…including sliding down a bank to race to a Waffle Jouse
With all John Green annoyances aside, I have to say I can’t help but admit this one is a cutesy, easy read. I still sped through it, even with the anger. I wouldn’t recommend it as much as the first story in Let It Snow, but I still enjoyed it in a very cheesy way.
Pete’s Review
What did you think of this story?
P.S. Merry Christmas Eve Eve from us both!
May your shelves forever overflow with books! ☽
















